Yesterday Evening I mentioned I was going to see 1968 film
Haseena Maan Jayegi.
Earlier I had compared old and new Hera Pheri so it came to mind let's compare the old and new
Haseena Maan Jayegi.
The 1968 one had mother Babita
The 1999 one had Daughter Karishma.
Haseena Maan Jayegi( 1968 )
Directed by Prakash Mehra
As the titles start ( in animation ) ones gets a feel of a comedy.
Rakesh (Shashi Kapoor) comes from a affluent family, but is the biggest Casanova in college. One that he does not impress is Archana (Babita). She rejects him and reports him to the principal when he behaves badly. Unfortunately, it is not Rakesh that gets the scolding, but Kamal Kumar (Shashi Kapoor). He looks just like him, but is just the opposite: a bright student who is willing to learn, whom Archana takes to heart after a few meetings. She wants to marry him even though he is orphaned and her father (Niranjan Sharma) does not like a relationship. Rather, he wants his daughter to marry Rakesh, who is the son of Mahavir's friend Randhir (Hari Shivdasani). After a few funny interludes finally Archana gets permission to marry Kamal.
Rakesh is a sore loser and always talked of taking Kamals place in Archana's life.
Post marriage both Kamal and Rakesh are commissioned to join the Army. They have a scuffle and one of them is killed (?). The survivor gets back to Archana who is intimated that Rakesh is killed. Her predicament starts.What follows is a court drama where it is proved who is who, why and how.
The second part suspense is maintained well.
For an actor, a double role is always appealing because it allows two different characters or at least different facets of a character to be brought onto the screen. Filmmakers and storytellers like to use the script of two similar characters to add drama and create a mix-up story. But here the double role is used differently.
( A little inspiration from Hum Dono and also readapted as Aasman with Rajiv Kapoor in 1984 ).
Shashi Kapoor has done both the roles well ( One sees a lot of Shammi Kapoor style in him ).
Babita has done well in a complicated role.
Johny Walker has a complete storyline for himself (unneeded as it looks now).
What makes the film memorable is the music by Kalyanji Anandji ( Chale the Saath Milke , Bekhudi main Sanam, Oh Dilbar Soniye are songs fresh even 52 years later.)
Shashi Kapoor has a unique distinction of working with his nephew's wives..
Babita and Neetu Singh and the pairs actually doesn't look out of place.
This was the debut of Prakash Mehra as a director.
Trivia : Babita was in his first film and her daughter Karishma in his last ( Bal Bramhachari )
Worth a watch even today.
-----------------------------------------------------------
Haseena Maan Jayegi ( 1999 )
Directed by David Dhawan.
David Dhawan has never been known for originality.This film is a clear Mix an match..
Theme from 1966 Pyaar Kiye Jaa
Title from 1968 HMJ
The plot of Kader Khan and his to sons Govinda and Sanjay Dutt was quite similar to David Dhawan's earlier film Aankhen 1993.Where his sons Chunkey Pandey and Govinda always put their father in trouble.
millionaire seth Amirchand (Kader Khan) has two spoilt sons; Monu (Govinda) and Sonu (Sanjay dutt). both are very lazy and are used to the rich and easy lifestyle. their father decides to put an end to this by not giving them any more money so both Monu & Sonu try to con their father through numerous pranks, which always backfires.
Seth Amirchand decides to have the two brothers separated in order to have better control and more influence on their lives. Sonu is sent to his father's office in mumbai while Monu is sent to goa to collect an unpaid debt on his father's behalf. while in goa Sonu meets and falls in love with Pooja (Pooja batra). at the same time Monu meets Ritu (Karishma Kapoor), who is staying at a girls hostel while attending medical college, and falls in love with her. both brothers doesn't know that ritu and pooja are sisters.
When Sonu wants to marry Pooja he goes to her father gulzarilal (Anupam Kher) to ask her hand in marriage, but scared of his strict father he tells Gulzarilal that his uncle will come instead making up some excuse why his father cannot come. but who does he find to play his uncle..? his brother monu of course, who disguises himself as an older man. ( Govinda in a creditable take on Kishore Kumar in Pyar Kiye Ja).
A sub plot is added where Gulzarilals Sister ( Aruna Irani ) falls for Chachaji..
There is also a Nepali Gurkha Paresh Rawal who thinks he is a detective.
The film does have several humorous situations especially whenever Govinda and Sanju trouble Kader Khan, It does have it's share of corny moments like Govinda and Karisma romance. The subplot of Pyaar Kiye Jaa although is humorous and the scenes between Aruna Irani and Govinda are funny. But what follows is identify crisis that will test the two brothers to the limit...
Direction is okay Music is decent, I Love You Bol Daal became famous,title song is good rest are okay
Govinda is simply brilliant in his role as always, Sanjay Dutt is Macho and t
he pairs well with Govinda, this was their comeback film after Taaqatwar,Do Qaidi and Andolan and was their first hit ( followed by Jodi No 1 , Ek aur Ek Gyarah) Karisma Kapoor does her usual act which she repeated in DD films though she entertain,Pooja Bhatra is glam and "stands tall" Anupam Kher hams as always,Aruna Irani is good Ashish Vidyarthi,Razzak Khan are cartoonish villains and apt Kader Khan is hilarious though he repeats his stuff Satish Kaushik is too good,as also Paresh Rawal.
Music is catchy but misses the melody ( Anu Malik ).
So verdict : I leave it to you to decide which is better.
Both Mother and Daughter have entertained .
My Choice : Music : 1968